Meet Tsuno at Sirha Lyon 2027 · Stand S.57Learn more
EN FR
Try the demo
Menu

Team and management

Should you consult employee representatives before using a voice assistant?

Yes, in France you must consult employee representatives (the CSE) before using a voice assistant once the company has 50 or more employees. Timelines and file.

Published on

In a restaurant dining room before service, five members of the team and management talk around a table covered with documents.

In France, yes, in any company with 50 or more employees that has a CSE (the comité social et économique, the elected employee representative body, close to what other countries call a works council). A voice assistant introduces a new technology (French Labour Code, Article L2312-8) and, as soon as it shows who did what and when, it becomes a means of monitoring employees' activity (Article L2312-38). In both cases, the CSE must be informed and consulted before the decision to implement it, not after. Between 11 and 49 employees, these consultations are not required on the same basis, but informing each employee beforehand remains mandatory. Other countries have equivalent bodies with their own rules. This article gives general guidance on French law, not legal advice: have your timeline checked by your lawyer.

Thursday, 10 a.m., a closed dining room, CSE meeting

A fictional group of six restaurants, 80 employees, one company. The HR director, Claire, plans to roll out a voice assistant in the kitchens in three weeks. She announces it at the end of the meeting, under "any other business". Sonia, an elected representative and chef de partie, puts down her pen: "Are you informing us or consulting us? Because a tool that knows when each of us did our checks is a monitoring tool. And we have not received a single document."

The meeting ends without a launch date. Claire was not wrong about the tool. She got the procedure wrong.

Why the question always comes up too late

The threshold is counted per company, not per restaurant

French labour law reasons in terms of the company. Six restaurants with 13 employees each, run by the same company, make one company of 78 employees, with the powers of a CSE in a company of 50 or more. Conversely, a franchise network usually has as many companies as it has operating businesses, each with its own headcount.

Two entry points, and a voice assistant often uses both

Article L2312-8 provides that the CSE is informed and consulted on "the introduction of new technologies". Article L2312-38 adds that it is informed and consulted, before the decision to implement them, on the means or techniques that allow monitoring of employees' activity. The same article requires prior information on automated personnel management systems. An assistant linked to tasks, checklists and routine checks touches both subjects, even when it is designed as support.

Informing is not consulting

Information is an announcement. Consultation is a procedure: precise written information, enough time to review it, an opinion from the CSE, then a reasoned response from the employer (Article L2312-15). The opinion is advisory, but the procedure is mandatory.

The thresholds, checked

  • 11 employees: a CSE is set up once the company has had at least 11 employees for 12 consecutive months (Article L2311-2).
  • 50 employees: the CSE's powers depend on headcount (Article L2312-1). The consultations under Articles L2312-8 and L2312-38 sit in the section on companies with 50 or more employees. When a company crosses that threshold after its CSE is in place, the CSE takes on these powers after a 12-month period (Article L2312-2).

Who has to do what, by company size (France)

SituationCSEWhat to do before go-live
Fewer than 11 employeesNo CSEInform each employee in writing (L1222-4), comply with the GDPR
11 to 49 employeesCSE without consultation powers on these subjectsInform each employee; presenting the tool to representatives is good practice, not a consultation duty under these articles
50 employees or moreCSE with broader powersInform and consult the CSE before deciding (L2312-8, L2312-38), then inform each employee
Several establishments with their own CSEsCentral and establishment CSEsCheck which level to consult, and plan around the timelines specific to that case

What the CSE will ask

  1. What exactly is the tool for? A one-sentence purpose, from the employee's point of view.
  2. Who sees what? Can the manager see the questions asked? Head office? Representatives want a precise answer, not "it depends".
  3. What is recorded, and for how long? Voice, text, timestamps, actions.
  4. Will it be used to score or discipline people? They will want a written commitment.
  5. Does it listen all the time? Does it analyse tone of voice? The CNIL does not accept permanent or systematic listening, and inferring emotions at work has been banned by the EU AI Act since 2 February 2025.
  6. What about someone who does not want to talk to a machine? An on-screen alternative must exist.

How to prepare the file

  1. A two-page briefing note: what the tool does, what it does not do, where it will be used (kitchen, storeroom, not in the dining room in front of guests).
  2. The purposes, one per line, with the legal basis chosen for each.
  3. The list of data processed, with retention periods and recipients.
  4. Employees' rights and how to exercise them.
  5. A usage policy: when to use it, what not to tell it (no health information about a colleague, for instance), who to report a problem to.
  6. The data protection impact assessment (DPIA) if the criteria are met, which is common for a new technology used by staff. The details are in a microphone at work: what the law says in France.
  7. The timeline: date the file is sent, date of the meeting, planned go-live date, after the opinion.

The timeline, without nasty surprises

  1. Send the written file. The consultation period starts when the information is provided, or when the employer announces it is available in the company's economic, social and environmental database (Article R2312-5).
  2. Allow one month, unless an agreement sets other timelines (Article L2312-16). This becomes two months if the CSE calls in an expert, and three months if expert reviews take place at both central and establishment level (Article R2312-6). When the period ends, the CSE is deemed to have given a negative opinion.
  3. Plan for an expert. When new technologies are introduced, the CSE may call in an approved expert (Article L2315-94), funded 80% by the employer and 20% by the CSE, with some exceptions (Article L2315-80).
  4. Answer in writing the CSE's questions and comments.
  5. Go live only after the opinion, given or deemed given, then inform each employee individually.

Common mistakes

  • Rolling out first, even "as a test". In a summary order of 14 February 2025 (case no. 24/01457), the Nanterre court of first instance (tribunal judiciaire) suspended the rollout of tools using artificial intelligence until the CSE consultation was complete, finding that the pilot phase relied on by the employer already amounted to implementation. It is a first-instance decision, but the signal is clear.
  • Describing a support tool in the language of monitoring. "Keep track of the team", "see who does their checks", "measure productivity": each phrase turns the file into a surveillance file.
  • Doing it all verbally. The CSE is entitled to precise written information. If something is missing, it can ask a judge to order the employer to provide it.
  • Forgetting establishment-level CSEs in a group organised by site.
  • Underestimating the risk. Obstructing the proper functioning of the CSE carries a fine of 7,500 euros (Article L2317-1), on top of the project being suspended.

What to measure

  • The gap between the date the file is sent and the go-live date: it must leave room for the consultation period.
  • The number of written questions from the CSE and your response time: a well-prepared file reduces them.
  • The share of employees informed individually before their first use: the target is 100%.

Where Tsuno fits in

Tsuno San, the intelligent voice assistant for frontline teams, is built so that a CSE file is simple to write, because its rules fit in one sentence each. San works within the person's permissions: it only sees and does what they can already see and do in Tsuno. Each person opens their session with the location code and their PIN. Every action takes two steps, San prepares and the person confirms, and it is logged. The AI does not score or rank employees, San evaluates no one and does not try to infer emotions, and Tsuno refuses to record special category data about an employee. San Voice is available as a demo; San Audio, the hands-free experience, is being explored and tested.

A CSE kit (briefing note, employee Q&A, usage policy, DPIA template) is in preparation. In the meantime, we support you through the process and answer your representatives' questions. For hosting, providers and the app's data retention, see the Trust and data page; for San's audio and text in real use, ask us in a meeting. San is presented on the Tsuno San page.

Further reading

The pillar page, Tsuno San, the work companion for frontline teams, gives the full picture. The personal data side is covered in a microphone at work: what the law says in France. For the arguments representatives are right to raise, read why management software can quickly feel like surveillance and software recalls the facts, people decide: a doctrine for AI in HR. To prepare the discussion with employee representatives, the pillar page AI, voice and privacy at work covers the points they raise most often.

Key takeaway

In France, from 50 employees, a voice assistant goes to the CSE before the decision, with a written file, and goes live after the opinion. Your best argument in front of representatives is a tool whose limits fit in a few verifiable sentences.

Frequently asked questions

What is the CSE in France?

The comité social et économique is the elected employee representative body in French companies, similar to a works council. It must be set up once a company has had at least 11 employees for 12 consecutive months, and it has broader information and consultation rights from 50 employees.

Is a voice assistant a way of monitoring employees' activity?

It can be, if it shows who did what and when, which is often the case for a tool linked to tasks and routine checks. Even when designed as support, it introduces a new technology. In both cases, under French law, the CSE of a company with 50 or more employees must be consulted before the decision.

How long does a CSE consultation take?

Unless an agreement sets other timelines, the CSE has one month from the date the information is provided, two months if it calls in an expert, and three months if expert reviews take place at both central and establishment level. After that, it is deemed to have given a negative opinion.

Can we pilot a voice assistant with a few employees before consulting the CSE?

It is risky. In February 2025, the Nanterre court of first instance, in summary proceedings, suspended the rollout of AI tools that the employer described as a pilot, finding that the pilot already amounted to implementation. Consult before any real use.

Do other countries have similar rules?

Many do. Several European countries have works councils or employee representative bodies with information and consultation rights on new technologies or monitoring. The details vary, so check the local rules in each country where you operate.